Elon Musk Shakes Up Twitter: New X Users to Pay for Likes and Replies

 

Elon Musk's acquisition of Twitter for $44 billion in October 2022 marked the beginning of a new era for the platform, now rebranded as "X" ^1 5. Under his leadership, X has seen unprecedented changes, including a significant reduction in workforce, the introduction of paid verification checkmarks, and the reevaluation of its content moderation strategies, signifying a pivotal shift in its operational and social engagement policies ^3 4. These sweeping changes have not only altered the platform's internal dynamics but have also sparked vigorous debates on its impact on freedom of speech and digital communication norms.

The restructuring of Twitter into X under Musk's tenure raises pertinent questions about the future of social media, content monetization, and user engagement. As the article unfolds, it will delve into the implications of Musk's announcement that new X users will have to pay for likes and replies, assess the impact on social media dynamics, explore the bot dilemma and Musk's innovative solutions, and gauge the reaction from the X community and the public at large ^3 4. Through a comparative lens with previous social media policies and an analysis of potential future implications, this discussion aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the transformative journey of Twitter under Elon Musk's reign.

Elon Musk's Announcement

Introduction of New Subscription Models

Elon Musk, in a series of strategic moves aimed at transforming X (formerly Twitter), announced the introduction of new subscription tiers and a unique program targeted at combating bot activities on the platform. Starting from October 27th, 2023, X introduced a multi-tier subscription system including Basic, Premium, and Premium+ levels, each offering progressively more features to enhance user experience. The most notable addition, however, is the 'Not A Bot' subscription, initially rolled out in New Zealand and the Philippines ⁸⁹¹².

Details of the 'Not A Bot' Program

The 'Not A Bot' program, specifically designed for new users, requires a minimal annual fee of $1. This initiative aims to verify genuine users and reduce spam and bot manipulation. New users opting for this program must verify their accounts with a phone number, and until they subscribe, their functionality is restricted to viewing posts and watching videos. This move is part of Musk's broader strategy to ensure transparency and improve the quality of interactions on the platform ⁹¹².

Strategic Implications and Musk's Vision

Musk articulated that charging new users is essential to curtail the pervasive issue of bots, which he believes could otherwise overwhelm the platform. He emphasized that this strategy is crucial for freeing up valuable username space and reducing the spread of inauthentic accounts. Musk's approach reflects a shift towards a user-validated model, moving away from the solely advertising-driven revenue model, which he argues, contributes to the proliferation of bot accounts ⁶¹²¹⁵.

Impact on Social Media Dynamics

Impact on Social Media Dynamics

1. User Engagement and Platform Growth
   Following Elon Musk's takeover, X (formerly Twitter) experienced a surge in active users, which initially suggested a positive reception to the new features like the "Tweet Undoing Feature" that allows users to retract tweets within 30 seconds of posting ¹⁶. However, despite these innovations, daily user statistics have shown a significant decline, with a 23% drop in American users since November 2022 ¹⁹. This trend is mirrored globally, with daily active users falling to 174 million, marking a 15% decline from the previous year ¹⁹.
2. Monetization vs. User Experience
   The shift to a monetization model through paid subscriptions like "Twitter Blue" and the introduction of the "Not A Bot" program was intended to enhance user experience and reduce bot activity ¹⁶. While these moves aim to provide an ad-free experience and exclusive content, they have sparked concerns about the erosion of authenticity and the potential overshadowing of valuable, diverse content due to enhanced promotion for paying users ¹⁸.
3. Business and Market Dynamics
   Businesses have the opportunity to leverage X’s paid subscriptions by tailoring exclusive content or promotions specifically for subscribers ¹⁶. Additionally, X has launched initiatives to share ad revenue generated from user replies with content creators, which could redefine engagement-based advertising opportunities ¹⁷. However, this strategy raises questions about the platform's role as a predictive tool for market sentiment and its long-term viability against competitors like Instagram and TikTok, which have seen lesser declines in user activity ^18 19.

The Bot Dilemma and Musk's Solution

Addressing the Bot Issue

Elon Musk's acquisition of Twitter, rebranded as X, brought with it a commitment to tackle the platform's longstanding bot problem. Musk has been vocal about the severity of the bot issue, even considering it significant enough to potentially back out of the Twitter purchase ²². Upon taking over, he promised sweeping reforms to eliminate bots and revamp the verification system. This included the introduction of a new system where users would pay $8 per month for a blue checkmark, intended to signify verified accounts ²².

Implementation of 'Not A Bot' and Verification Changes

The 'Not A Bot' program is a direct response to these challenges. For a nominal annual fee of $1, new users can post content and engage with others, aiming to ensure that active accounts are operated by real individuals ⁶. However, despite these measures, challenges persist. Reports have surfaced of increased advertisements from accounts displaying the blue checkmark without any prior posts, suggesting these may be compromised accounts ²². Moreover, there is skepticism about the effectiveness of the paid verification in actually reducing bot activity, as noted problems with bot accounts persist even among those that are verified ²³.

Musk's Strategy and Ongoing Challenges

Musk's strategy also included significant changes to Twitter's API access and developer agreements, which now prevent developers from creating products that mimic the app's core functionalities ³. Additionally, in a controversial move in June 2023, Twitter began blocking unregistered users from viewing tweets or profiles, citing unspecified 'long-standing API rules' ³. These actions reflect Musk's aggressive approach to controlling the platform's ecosystem and addressing its issues, yet they also raise questions about the overall effectiveness and future impact of these strategies on user engagement and platform authenticity ²²²³.

Reaction from the X Community and Public

Public Backlash and Controversies

1. User Discontent: The announcement of subscription fees for likes and replies has led to widespread dissatisfaction among users. Many have voiced their intentions to abandon the platform if these changes are implemented, with a notable number expressing their frustrations on social media ⁵.
2. #RIPTwitter Trend: In response to Elon Musk's new policies, the hashtag #RIPTwitter has gained significant traction, symbolizing the community's protest against the proposed monetization strategies ⁵.
3. Migration to Competitors: The discontent has not only been vocal but also action-oriented, with some users threatening to transition their social media activity to rival platforms, seeking more user-friendly alternatives without additional costs ⁵.

Controversial Decisions and Labeling

• Journalist Suspensions: The suspension of several journalists in December 2022 stirred significant controversy, leading to the temporary shutdown of Twitter Spaces. This action raised concerns about the platform's commitment to freedom of the press and expression ³.
• Media Labeling: In a move that further fueled debate, X designated NPR as 'US state-affiliated media' in April 2023. This label is typically reserved for foreign media outlets that represent their government's interests, thus sparking discussions about the platform's impartiality and the accuracy of such classifications ³.

Shift in Platform Dynamics

• From Social to Anti-Social: There has been a noticeable shift in the nature of interactions on X. The platform, under Musk’s leadership emphasizing free speech, has seen an increase in misinformation and hate speech. This transformation has led some users and observers to describe X as becoming more of an 'anti-social network' rather than a space for positive social engagement ².

Comparison with Previous Social Media Policies

Twitter Blue vs. Meta Verified

1. Subscription Services: Twitter introduced Twitter Blue, which provides features such as a blue checkmark, bookmark folders, tweet editing, longer tweets, personalization, top articles, and two-factor authentication via text ²⁴. In contrast, Meta (Facebook and Instagram) launched Meta Verified, offering a verified badge, increased visibility, human support, proactive account protection, and exclusive stickers ²⁴.
2. Cost Comparison: Twitter Blue is priced at $8 per month or $84 annually ²⁴. Meanwhile, Meta Verified is more expensive, costing $11.99 monthly on the web or $14.99 on iOS ²⁴.

Policy Changes Under Musk's Leadership

• Content Moderation and Verification Overhaul: Elon Musk overhauled Twitter's previous verification system, replacing it with Twitter Blue, which costs $8 per month. This move aimed to democratize the verification process but led to issues such as impersonation risks ²⁵. Musk initially planned a content moderation council but later made significant policy changes unilaterally, including revoking Trump's suspension without consultation ²⁵.
• Handling of Media and Controversial Accounts: Musk faced backlash for labeling media organizations as 'state-funded media' and later had to retract these labels. He also controversially removed bans on accounts, including those associated with Neo-Nazis, and disbanded the existing Trust and Safety Council ²⁵.

Potential Future Implications

Subscription Model and Monetization Strategy

1. Initial Subscription Fee for New Users: All new accounts on Twitter X will be required to pay a $1 annual subscription fee to engage with content, marking a significant shift towards a subscriber-only platform ¹¹. This fee, applicable only to new users, will not impact existing members of the platform ¹¹.
2. Limited Duration for Fee: Initially, this subscription fee might be imposed only for the first three months following a user's registration, suggesting a trial period to assess user response and system effectiveness ¹³.
3. Global Expansion and Eligibility: The subscription model is not limited to specific regions, as evidenced by the pilot schemes in New Zealand and the Philippines. This global approach includes a range of features such as exclusive posts and subscriber-only spaces, aiming to incentivize content creation and interaction within the platform ¹³²⁶.

Creator Economy and Revenue Sharing

• Monetization Opportunities for Creators: Twitter X's subscription model offers creators the chance to earn monthly income through the content they produce. By meeting certain criteria such as having a minimum of 500 followers and being active in the past 30 days, creators can participate in this monetization scheme ²⁶.
• Revenue Sharing Model: Creators will receive a share of the revenue generated from subscribers who pay to access their content. However, payments to creators are contingent upon the platform recording a minimum amount of $50 attributed to the creator's content ²⁶.

Regulatory Compliance and Payment Rollout

• Secured Licenses for Money Transmission: Twitter X has proactively obtained money transmission licenses in 14 states. This strategic move is crucial for the phased rollout of peer-to-peer payments, potentially transforming the platform into a more comprehensive financial ecosystem ²⁰.

Conclusion

Elon Musk's radical transformation of Twitter into X has sparked a multifaceted debate on the future of social media interactivity, monetization strategies, and the battle against inauthentic engagement. Through the introduction of subscription models, such as the 'Not A Bot' program, and the controversial decision to charge new users for likes and replies, Musk's strategies have shifted X's paradigm profoundly. These changes underscore a definitive move away from an ad-supported model towards a user-validated system, aimed at enhancing authenticity and user experience. However, the impact on user engagement, platform growth, and the broader implications for the digital communication landscape remain a subject of intense scrutiny and debate.

As we look forward, the reactions from the X community and the public further illustrate the delicate balance between innovation and user inclusivity in shaping the future of social media platforms. The potential implications of these strategies on the creator economy, revenue sharing models, and the regulatory landscape are both significant and uncertain. Although Musk's efforts to combat bots and monetize the platform are clear, the broader impacts on social media dynamics, user interaction, and market competition warrant continued observation and analysis. Ultimately, the success of these initiatives in creating a sustainable and engaging digital ecosystem will depend on their ability to adapt to user feedback and navigate the complexities of digital communication norms.

FAQs

1. Will X start charging its users? Yes, X, formerly known as Twitter, will begin charging new users. Elon Musk has announced that new users will need to pay a nominal fee to like, post, reply, and bookmark tweets.
2. What is Elon Musk's net worth? (Answer not provided in the original input.)
3. Who is Elon Musk? Elon Musk, originally from Pretoria, South Africa, is a globally recognized entrepreneur. He is best known as the CEO of Tesla, the electric car company, and SpaceX, a private space exploration company.

References

[1] - https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2023/10/05/elon-musk-twitter-news/71066360007/
[2] - https://www.forbes.com/sites/petersuciu/2023/11/08/twitter-has-changed-a-lot-since-elon-musk-bought-it-a-year-ago/
[3] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_under_Elon_Musk
[4] - https://www.dw.com/en/x-how-elon-musk-changed-twitter-in-one-year/a-67220997
[5] - https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/twitter-x-users-react-plans-212732769.html
[6] - https://www.macrumors.com/2024/04/15/x-small-fee-new-users/
[7] - https://m.economictimes.com/news/international/us/x-may-charge-users-monthly-fee-says-elon-musk-heres-what-happened/articleshow/103792090.cms
[8] - https://help.twitter.com/en/using-x/x-premium
[9] - https://www.theverge.com/2023/10/17/23921752/x-not-a-bot-charge-new-users-elon-musk
[10] - https://www.techdirt.com/2023/09/19/elon-who-insisted-he-had-solved-the-spam-bot-problem-now-says-he-will-paywall-twitter-to-stop-spam-bots/
[11] - https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2023-10-18/x-pilot-program-to-charge-1-a-year-in-effort-to-combat-bots-spam
[12] - https://techcrunch.com/2024/04/15/elon-musk-plans-to-charge-new-x-users-to-enable-posting/
[13] - https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-13318785/Elon-Musk-charging-X-users-like-reply-tweets.html
[14] - https://www.forbes.com/sites/antoniopequenoiv/2024/04/15/musk-will-charge-new-x-users-small-fee-for-posting-tweet-suggests/
[15] - https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/news/story/x-to-charge-money-from-new-users-for-posting-liking-and-replying-to-tweets-2527645-2024-04-16
[16] - https://anytimedigitalmarketing.com/2023/08/08/twitter-vs-x-unpacking-musks-social-media-revolution/
[17] - https://www.spiceworks.com/marketing/advertising/guest-article/social-media-monetization-strategies/
[18] - https://medium.com/@arnavmehta011/in-elon-musks-strategy-to-monetize-x-formerly-known-as-twitter-by-introducing-paid-41739b518993
[19] - https://time.com/6961456/elon-musk-x-twitter-updates-changes-premium-features/
[20] - https://www.financemagnates.com/fintech/payments/tweetonomics-how-xs-peer-to-peer-payments-could-reshape-commerce/
[21] - https://chiefmachers.com/technology/from-twitter-to-x-unpacking-the-implications-of-the-everything-app/
[22] - https://fortune.com/2023/12/01/elon-musk-x-twitter-bots-ads-fake-luxury-goods/
[23] - https://techcrunch.com/2024/01/10/it-sure-looks-like-x-twitter-has-a-verified-bot-problem/
[24] - https://www.aarp.org/home-family/personal-technology/info-2023/social-media-fees.html
[25] - https://time.com/6274774/elon-musk-twitter-u-turns/
[26] - https://help.twitter.com/en/using-x/subscriptions-creator
[27] - https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/27/technology/elon-musk-twitter-year.html